avenue-logo
Schedule a Call

Hi! I'm Paul McArtor.

  • Hidden
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Hi! My name is Paul McArtor. Gratefully the Air Force moved us to Charlottesville for my last assignment and we fell in love right away. Staying here here after I retired was an easy decision. I started doing real estate as a hobby while I was active duty including rehabbing houses, owning rental properties, and helping friends buy. It was an easy decision to put that 16+ years of experience to use and become a REALTOR.

I enjoy the problem solving of real estate. My job is done well when my clients think the whole process was easy and stress-free. I call myself a stress sponge. It’s such a great feeling when clients get the keys to their new house or when my sellers get the wire from their sale.

As someone that wasn’t born and raised in Charlottesville, I feel like I have a very important experience. I have moved to Charlottesville. I know the trials and tribulations of needing to find a new home in a new place. There are so many unique areas around Charlottesville with each having their positives and negatives. It’s a benefit to my clients both local and relocating to be able to show these options and help them determine the best fit for them.

I love this job!

A few of my favorite things

Favorite hobby

As a family we love to travel and explore the areas around C’ville. I’m a big “foodie”, so I love exploring the resturants around town.

Favorite team

I’m originally from the Tampa Bay area, so I am a dedicated Buccaneer fan. It’s a hard life to live, but I can’t give up on them.

Favorite holiday

Halloween is my favorite. Everyone gets to act like a kid. Watching my daughters run around in their costumes makes me smile.

Client Testimonials

"I have had the pleasure of working with Paul McArtor and Pam Whorley while purchasing my home. I can not stress enough the ease and comfort of working with them! Paul always looked out for my best interest and went above and beyond to help me find information. Paul saw and walked over 60 acres with me with a smile and genuine excitement for my finds! I asked for a ribbon cutting, and Paul even helped make that happen!!! When he had a prior engagement, Pam came and helped him out and she was fabulous as well! If you need a realtor for your sale or purchase, there’s no doubt, you’d be in excellent hands with Paul or Pam!"
- Katherine G.
"Paul McArtor, gave us quality service. The amount of questions we had for him and he was able to answer all of them. We were very impressed with his professional approach and patients while we looked for our new home. Thanks Paul."
- Benjamin & Veona M.
"I loved working with Paul McArtor to purchase my very first home! As a first-time home buyer, I was nervous about the whole process, but he helped guide me through it all and taught me so much along the way. I knew if I had questions about any of the homes I viewed, he would have answers or know where to get those answers.  I was so happy with how smooth the process went in the end, and I'm thrilled with my new home!  He made this huge "mystery" process smooth, easy, and most of all fun."
- Ronda G.
"Wonderful experience working with Paul McArtor. He took care of us through the entire process from thinking we were going to wait another year to buy, to getting on the phone with us the very next day as we explored options and ended up getting the house we recently closed on. Even since closing he's checked in on us and answered any questions we've had from recommendations for contractors to making sense of some of the mail we've gotten regarding our mortgage. Paul took care of connecting us with a great home inspector and built a relationship between us and the builder. There's a reason he won Best of C'Ville's Best Real Estate Agent."
- Nicolo P.
"Where do I even begin… Paul McArtor is the BEST! Being first time homebuyers, my husband and I didn’t know much about the real estate world. However, with Paul’s knowledge and expertise we were able to successfully make it through the process of not only buying, but building our first home. He helped educate us and guide us throughout a process we couldn’t have completed without him. We could always count on his honest advice, quick responses, flexible availability, and willingness to explain anything we asked… no matter what time it was or how long it took! He is so personable, kind, and extremely trustworthy. He managed to keep us calm and confident in the biggest purchase of our lives! He really went above and beyond in helping us. We are so grateful for Paul who has turned into not just our real estate agent, but a lifelong friend. We HIGHLY recommend you reach out to Paul as we have absolutely no doubt he will be the best real estate agent you could ask for. So do yourself a favor and choose Paul! Thank you Paul for making this process so fun and so easy!"
- Alyssa H.
"We had an absolutely incredible experience working with Paul McArtor. We were first time buyers and completely unfamiliar with the processes of looking for and purchasing a home. Paul was invaluable in guiding us through the process, answering our truly endless questions, being so accommodating in seeing every property (some more than once) that we wanted to see, helping curate lists of properties based on what we wanted, and always enthusiastically answering our calls, texts, and emails. After we bought the house we now live in, he even provided lists of social events and neighborhood activities to help us settle into the community. I truly cannot think of how anyone could have been more friendly, communicative, kind, generous, and unwaveringly helpful in this process. We are Paul fans for life."
- Erin C.
"Paul Is the best!!! In all areas he was the finest realtor we have ever dealt with. He is always available and handled every detail in a timely and professional manner. We feel we have made a new friend."
- Dave & Bonnie H.
"My husband and I reached out to Paul McArtor after seeing his great reviews online and we can say he absolutely lived up to them. As first time homebuyers Paul’s experience and expertise were invaluable throughout the entire process. He gave us insight at each showing and helped us ask the right questions. It didn’t take long before we found our perfect home and he helped us draft a competitive offer and then put us in touch with a great home inspector and title company. Anytime anyone asks us for a realtor we always recommend Paul!"
- Rebecca K.
Paul was truly an amazing asset to our home buying experience! He listened to our wants and needs, showing us homes in different parts of Charlottesville, helping us ultimately find a lot and then a home builder. He was a great communicator and really looked out for our best interests. I would recommend Paul highly.
- Shelby R.
Paul McArtor Is a wonderful agent that I would recommend highly to anyone I know is looking for a house. He is very willing to help and also answer any questions you might have. He makes recommendations on solutions to anything that might be a problem for you. And keeps working to help find you your perfect house. I would give him more than 5 stars if I could. Thanks to him we found ours.
- Pat & Hugo
"I highly recommend Avenue Realty. Paul is so, so great to work with. He really cared about finding us the right home. I was a first time homebuyer and I can't imagine going through the process without him. He went above and beyond and was always on the ball with everything from start to finish. We closed on our home at the end of April and I couldn't be happier!"
- Alicia May
"Paul McArtor and Avenue Realty provided top quality service during the selling process of our townhome in Charlottesville. They provided us with staging advice, excellent photography, and the smoothest selling process we could have wished for. Paul and the Avenue Realty team, thank you again!"
- Jeroen D.
"Paul was awesome to work with."
- Sujay N.
"I was very pleased with the service Paul McArtor provided. He went to great trouble to obtain information I requested about the property. He also secured the services of an excellent home inspector and helped me find contractors to assist with remodeling various aspects of the house."
- James L.
"My husband and I just relocated to VA from TX. No easy feat. Paul McArtor assisted in helping us find a new home. Paul is friendly, professional and comes with a wealth of knowledge. He helped us in so many ways. I highly recommend Paul if you are thinking about any real estate transactions. Excellent service!!!"
- Sandra W.
"This was our second time working with Paul McArtor and it was once again a great experience. Paul was there every step of the way as we purchased our new house, providing his wisdom and insight in any and all situations. He is very available and always enthusiastic while his knowledge of homes and the home building/buying process is an unbelievable asset."
- Silas C.
"Paul McArtor of Avenue Realty just helped us buy our first home and made what seemed an intimidating process at first go so smoothly - even with our limited budget. From explaining everything to us in detail, to answering questions we didn't even know we should ask, to stopping more than once to help my toddler get her shoes back on as we toured multiple homes... we couldn't ask for a more helpful and personable realtor. He was never pushy or impatient with us, truly seemed to care that we were happy with our purchase and has a whole team of people to recommend for every aspect of the home-buying process (all of which are just as helpful and personable as he is). Our family absolutely recommends hiring Paul McArtor as your next Charlottesville-area realtor!"
- Jessica F.
"Paul helped us to find an apartment with less than the time we were looking at with attaching us to a portal and as soon as anything posted we would able to see it. He is a really great responder and works through anything you would like to communicate with such as texting, calling, or email and follow up as much as he could to make sure we will get all information. I will work with him again soon. Thanks Paul for all the work you've done"
- Sadegh S.
"Paul did an amazing job. He was able to market and sell my home all while I was out of state. Great communicator and was very diligent with details and time frames. I would definitely recommend him to any one looing to buy or sell. Thanks again Paul!"
- Reyes R.
"We worked with Paul McArtor when buying our home, and he was truly wonderful! He was incredibly responsive when we reached out (and proactively would reach out to us.) Additionally, he was so knowledgeable and made us feel much more confident in buying our first home! I cannot recommend him highly enough."
- Erin Z.
"Paul McArtor's knowledge and patience helped us find our forever home in Lake Monticello. Hes been a great source of vendors, painters, etc and always answered all our questions and concerns. What a pleasure working with Paul."
- Tina M.
"Paul McArtor helped me buy a piece of land in Earlysville. I am a first time buyer and he was very patient and professional. He walked me through every step of the process and answered all my questions. He was easy to work with and very responsive to my calls/texts. If I have any real estate needs in the future, I will definitely reach out to him again. Highly recommended! Thanks, Paul!"
- Simran M.
"Had a great experience with Paul McArtor at Avenue. He did a fantastic job of leading us through the process of selling our home, answering all of questions and explaining each step. We recommend him highly."
- Charles E.
Previous
Next

Recently Sold

30 Spring Ct, Charlottesville, VA 22901

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath condo nestled in Charlottesville’s desirable Four Seasons community. Ideally located just minutes from the Shops at Stonefield, Route 29, I-64, and UVA, this home offers unmatched convenience to shopping, dining, and commuter routes.

8 Sandy Beach Ct, Palmyra VA 22963

Tucked among the trees, this charming home offers the peaceful feel of a woodland retreat with the convenience of neighborhood living. A circular driveway welcomes you to the inviting front porch, setting the tone for the warmth inside.

693 Oland St, Ruckersville, VA 22968

Welcome to this beautifully designed home, where natural light and open-concept living greet you upon entry. The main level features luxury vinyl plank flooring, a spacious living room, and a well-appointed kitchen with ample cabinetry, generous counter space, an island with bar seating, and a pantry.

3228 Bergen St, Charlottesville VA 22902

Enjoy effortless first-floor living in this stunning end-unit villa. Step into a welcoming foyer that opens to an airy layout with soaring 10’ ceilings and luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout. The upgraded gourmet kitchen features a large island, abundant counter space, gas range, big pantry, and a bar perfect for entertaining.

437 Larchmont Cir, Ruckersville, VA 22968

Welcome to this beautifully designed home offering unmatched flexibility! The striking stone accents and inviting curb appeal make a lasting first impression. Inside, a spacious living room flows seamlessly into the formal dining area.

3414 Montague St, Charlottesville VA 22902

Enjoy your panoramic view of Carter Mountain! This like-new townhouse is beautifully appointed and ready to be your new home. As you enter, you will find a flexible space with attached half bath to use as a rec room, home office, or guest space.

935 Marsac St, Charlottesville VA 22901

This stunning like-new construction offers the perfect blend of comfort and functionality with maintenance-free, main-level living. The open-concept design features a spacious great room and a gourmet kitchen with upgraded cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and luxury vinyl plank flooring.

2940 Templehof Ct, Earlysville VA 22936

Wonderful end unit townhome in an awesome location! As you approach your new home you are welcomed with a cozy front porch. Walking through the front door enters the main level living room.

3444 Montague St, Charlottesville VA 22902

Admire wonderful mountain views from the comfort of your living room! This beautiful luxury end-unit home has everything you want. As you enter the house you are greeted in a light filled foyer.

3124 Turnberry Cir, Charlottesville, VA 22911

A wonderful, wrap around front porch welcomes you to your beautiful new home in the sought after Springridge section of Forest Lakes! As you enter you are greeted with a lovely floor plan with tons of flexibility. Enjoy the living room with walls of windows, family room with a fireplace, & comfortable den.

6 James River Rd, Palmyra VA 22963

As you approach this beautiful single level home you are welcomed by the cozy covered porch. Enter the front door to find your living room with a stone fireplace and vaulted ceiling. Continue to find your kitchen with updated appliances which opens to your dining area.

4429 Sunset Dr, Charlottesville, VA 22911

Enjoy a glass of wine watching the sunset over the mountains from your back deck! This wonderful house is ready to be your new home. As you walk in the front door, you will see a lovely dining room that could be used as a flex space.

3675 Mayfield Rd, Rockingham, VA 22801

This wonderful former model home is ready to be yours! As you enter, you will experience the open floorplan with luxury vinyl plank floors and natural light throughout the main common area.

3241 Bergen St, Charlottesville VA 22902

Enjoy your panoramic view of Carter Mountain from your private roof top terrace! This beautiful home has exclusive upgrades only found in this house. As you enter the house you are greeted in a light-filled foyer.

2314 Avinity Ct, Charlottesville, VA 22902

This beautiful luxury townhome has everything you want! As you enter, the bottom floor has a great multi-purpose room which is the perfect guest suite with attached bath or additional large family/recreation room.

978 Towne Ln, Charlottesville VA 22901

Location, Location, Location!! This terrific townhouse is close to Downtown, UVA, and the Hwy 29 corridor. Your main floor includes an eat-in kitchen with newer appliances along with plenty of cabinet and countertop space.

85 Greene Lea Dr, Ruckersville, VA 22968

Wonderful Greene County home minutes to NGIC/DIA and Charlottesville! As you enter, you will see real hardwood floors. The spacious living room gives plenty of flexibility. The eat-in kitchen provides tons of storage and countertop space.

2409 Winthrop Dr, Charlottesville VA 22911

Enjoy the feel of a detached home with all the benefits of a townhouse! As you walk through the front door you enter your main level. The spacious living room gives you flexibility for furniture.

21 West Lake Forest Dr, Palmyra VA 22963

Wonderful single level home ready for you! Walk up the brick pathway towards your front door. As you enter you will see beautiful hardwood floors throughout the living and dining room. The living room’s vaulted ceiling and large windows create a feeling of space and openness that continues to the dining area.

793 Geranium Rd, Ruckersville VA 22968

Discover your waterfront oasis! Mature trees lead you to a covered front patio. As you enter you are welcomed by a living room with vaulted ceiling & cozy fireplace. Glance over to see your open kitchen with plenty of counterspace & newer appliances.

396 Cunningham Meadows Dr, Palmyra VA 22963

Like-new home on a gorgeous lot! As you enter you are welcomed by beautiful hardwood floors flowing throughout the main level. Your open kitchen overlooks the living room to allow socializing while cooking.

237 Jonquil Rd, Ruckersville VA 22968

Beautiful one level home built in 2020! Come see the top-level finishes throughout this home. As you pull up to the home you will see a large yard perfect for play!

3409 Montague St, Charlottesville VA 22902

Wonderful first floor, single level living in sought after AVINITY! Enter into your natural light filled foyer with high ceilings and into your upgraded kitchen with stunning granite, abundance of cabinet space and oversized pantry.

You want to sell your home. Let's discuss it.

Experience the stress-free way of selling your home, let’s discuss today!

* Other terms & conditions apply. Seller must enroll in the program prior to listing their home.

Discuss Selling Your Home Today

Sitemap

  • © Copyright 2023, Avenue Realty, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Skip to toolbar